Looming Franchise Failure

 

The ultimate risk for any potential investor in a traditional travel franchise such as Expedia Cruises is not just declining margins or shrinking customer demand — it is the existential risk of franchise failure. Historical precedent, current industry trends, and rapid technological disruption all point to a trajectory where brick-and-mortar travel agencies face the same fate as industries that failed to adapt to digital transformation.

 

 

___________________________

 

 

1. Lessons from the Airline Industry

 

The airline industry offers one of the most direct and sobering examples of how an entire distribution model can be upended:

 

  • 1990s Shift in Distribution: Airlines once relied heavily on travel agents to distribute tickets. At the peak, agents handled 80% of airline sales worldwide.

 

  • Zero Commissions: Beginning in the late 1990s, major airlines cut and eventually eliminated base commissions paid to agents. By 2002, U.S. airlines offered 0% commission, shifting entirely to direct sales and online platforms.

 

  • Outcome: The traditional travel agent’s role in airline bookings all but vanished. Today, almost no consumer books flights through an agent unless it’s part of a corporate or luxury package.

 

This history is critical for potential franchise buyers: the cruise industry is following the same path. Cruise lines, like airlines, are investing heavily in direct-to-consumer platforms, loyalty ecosystems, and AI-driven personalization. Commissions — the lifeblood of travel agencies — are increasingly seen as an unnecessary expense.

 

 

___________________________

 

 

2. The Blockbuster Analogy

 

The Blockbuster story provides another stark warning. Once a household name with over 7,000 locations globally, Blockbuster thrived under a physical storefront model. However:

 

  • They failed to anticipate and adapt to digital disruption (Netflix, streaming, and on-demand services).

 

  • Consumers embraced the convenience and lower cost of digital platforms almost overnight.

 

  • Within a decade, Blockbuster collapsed to zero operating locations.

 

Travel franchises are now in a similar position: operating under a brick-and-mortar model that is outdated, while their own parent companies and suppliers accelerate digital transformation. Like Blockbuster, they risk becoming relics of a bygone era.

 

 

___________________________

 

 

3. Cruise Industry Dependence

 

Expedia Cruises’ business model is particularly fragile because of its overreliance on the cruise industry:

 

  • Cruise commissions are under scrutiny: Cruise lines such as Carnival, Norwegian, and Royal Caribbean have all signaled an intent to drive more direct bookings. Norwegian Cruise Line already reported more direct bookings than agency-driven sales.

 

  • Direct booking incentives: Onboard credits, loyalty discounts, and app-based upgrades encourage customers to bypass agents.

 

  • Digital transformation in cruise lines: Companies are rolling out AI-driven recommendation engines, mobile-first booking apps, and personalized upselling tools. Each of these reduces reliance on third-party sellers.

 

For a franchise so heavily tied to cruise sales, this represents an existential risk. If airlines moved to 0% commissions, why would cruise lines not eventually follow the same path?

 

___________________________

 

 

4. The Vulnerability of Travel Insurance Commissions

 

Another lucrative revenue stream for Expedia Cruises is travel insurance sales, often paying commissions of 25% or more. While this currently cushions overall earnings, the same digital disruption threatens this segment:

 

  • Insurtech companies (AI-powered travel insurance platforms) are entering the market with direct-to-consumer sales at lower premiums, cutting out the agent.

 

  • Cruise lines themselves increasingly offer bundled travel protection products during the booking process, capturing commissions in-house.

 

  • AI comparison tools make it easier for consumers to shop policies instantly, reducing the incentive to buy from an agent.

 

As AI adoption spreads, insurance commissions are likely to shrink significantly, removing another pillar of profitability for franchises.

 

 

___________________________

 

 

5. The Domino Effect of Industry Shifts

 

When we combine these risks, a picture emerges of a franchise model on the brink:

 

  • Shrinking commissions from cruise lines.

 

  • Digital-first consumer behavior preferring mobile and AI tools.

 

  • Overhead-heavy brick-and-mortar costs with declining foot traffic.

 

  • Insurance commissions at risk from digital disruption.

 

  • Parent company competition — Expedia Group itself prioritizes its online AI-powered platforms over physical agencies.

 

This combination mirrors both the airline commission collapse and the Blockbuster digital disruption — suggesting the endgame is not just slower growth, but outright franchise obsolescence.

 

 

___________________________

 

 

 

Conclusion: A Franchise Model on Borrowed Time

 

The writing on the wall is clear. Just as airlines cut commissions to zero and Blockbuster collapsed under digital competition, the travel franchise model faces an unavoidable reckoning. Expedia Cruises’ reliance on cruise commissions and insurance revenue creates vulnerability, while their own parent company competes directly through online platforms.

 

For potential investors, this represents not just a high-risk, low-return investment, but one with a credible path to complete failure. The looming collapse is not a matter of “if,” but when.

 

 

___________________________

___________________________